Shop by Category
Holidays / Popular Halloween Gifts & Games
Trick or treat yourself to these boo-tiful Halloween picks! We've scared up the most amazing spooky season gifts that'll make your October gift exchange extra haunting. No tricks, just treats!
Elfster may earn a small commission through clicks or purchases made to external sites, which helps keep the workshop humming. Elfster may earn a small commission through clicks or purchases made to external sites. Read more
Comfy Plush Lightweight House Slippers
Wished for 2368 times
$19.99
Price as of 12/3/2024
Halloween Throw Blanket 50"×60"
Wished for 916 times
$19.99
Price as of 12/3/2024
Black Hair Clip with Skeleton Skull Design
Wished for 472 times
$7.99
Price as of 12/3/2024
5PCS Halloween Straw Cover Cap for Stanley Cup
Wished for 897 times
$7.99
Price as of 12/3/2024
Spooky Cutie: Coloring Book for Adults
Wished for 962 times
$7.99
Price as of 7/29/2024
The Beauty of Horror: A GOREgeous Coloring Book
Wished for 1683 times
$11.34
Price as of 7/19/2024
Not finding what you're looking for? You can shop from any store! Write in a wish or download our browser extension.
Hunt A Killer Death at The Dive Bar
Wished for 16 times
$22.39
Price as of 12/3/2024
This Is My Halloween Costume T-Shirt
Wished for 3 times
$15.95
Price as of 11/7/2024
Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Brown Oogie Boogie - Nightmare Before Christmas
Wished for 1629 times
$17.99
Price as of 12/4/2024
The Pumpkin Spice Quencher H2.O FlowState™ Tumbler I 40 OZ
Wished for 2484 times
The Nightmare Before Christmas Tarot Deck and Guidebook
Wished for 15 times
$23.24
Price as of 11/27/2024
X
X
X