Shop by Category
>
Yankee Swap Gifts — Picks Everyone Will Fight Over

Yankee Swap Gifts — Picks Everyone Will Fight Over

Universally appealing, steal-worthy finds for your next Yankee Swap or White Elephant party

amazon.com
Kaluns Grilling Accessories, Dad Gifts for Fathers Day, Mothers Day Grilling Gifts, Heavy Duty Stain
Wished for 304 times
$29.98
Buy Now
amazon.com
Homsolver Gifts for Women, Mothers Day Gift for Friends, Birthday Gifts for Women, Friendship Gift f
$9.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
Marycele Candle Warmer Lamp with Timer & Dimmer - Mothers Day Gifts for Women Mom Her, Aesthetic Off
Wished for 1,307 times
$22.79
Buy Now
amazon.com
Nostalgia HDT600RETRORED Retro Pop-Up 2 Hot Dog and Bun Toaster, With Mini Tongs, Works With Chicken
Wished for 250 times
$32.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
RMFSH Candle Warmer Lamp with Timer Dimmable, Birthday Gifts for Women Mom, House Warming Gifts New
Wished for 9 times
$15.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
The Ultimate New York Yankees Trivia Book: A Collection of Amazing Trivia Quizzes and Fun Facts for
Wished for 11 times
$9.18
Buy Now
amazon.com
Bonsai Starter Kit - Gardening Birthday Gifts for Women & Men - Bonsai Tree Growing Garden Crafts Ho
Wished for 315 times
$14.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
Best Yankee Swap Gift Ever Shirt T-Shirt
$20.00
Buy Now
amazon.com
White Elephant Gift Fart Joke Gag Christmas Yankee Swap Gifts Funny Gifts for Him Joke Pill Box Pran
$10.99
Buy Now
etsy.com
Handmade Felt Pepperoni Pizza Ornament - Pizza Slice Ornament Miniature Food Funny Fun Yankee Swap Gift Small Gift
Wished for 1 time
$20.00
Buy Now
etsy.com
Funny Photo Gift, Face Personalized Yankee Swap, Mug, Secret Santa Gift For Men
$15.97
Buy Now
etsy.com
2026 Pooping Pooches Dog Calendar, White Elephant Gag Gift Exchange Or Yankee Swap
Wished for 9 times
$14.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
Gag Gifts for Men Funny Gifts Prank Pill Box White Elephant Christmas Yankee Swap Funny Prank Gift B
Wished for 1 time
$7.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
Worlds Smallest Violin Joke White Elephant Gift for Him Christmas Yankee Swap for Her Secret Santa G
Wished for 3 times
$10.99
Buy Now
etsy.com
Custom Dinner Decision Game, Date Night Tokens, Funny Christmas Gift, White Elephant, Yankee Swap Couple Or Family Gift
$29.00
Buy Now
etsy.com
Family Fun Tokens | Christmas Gift For Kids Activity Game Stocking Stuffer Screen-Free Night Secret Santa Yankee Swap
$23.00
Buy Now
nordstrom.com
YANKEE CANDLE Signature Votive Mini Candle Jars, 12 Days of Christmas Candle Advent Calendar Variety Pack in Multicolored at Nordstrom
$59.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
Yankee Swap Christmas Party Exchange Stainless Steel Insulated Tumbler
$26.99
Buy Now
etsy.com
Custom Indiana Jones couples face Swap portraits, Be the Hero Custom Indy Portrait Swap Gift
$55.00 & up
Buy Now
amazon.com
Funny Worst Yankee Swap Ever T-shirt Christmas Saying Stainless Steel Insulated Tumbler
$26.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
Santa Swap Gift Exchange Dice, 3 * 3in Exchange Gifts Family Game, Christmas Stocking Stuffers Gift
Wished for 2 times
$9.99
Buy Now
etsy.com
New York Yankee Sign. Baseball Wood Joe Dimaggio Baseball Home Decor. Yankees Gift. Gift
$63.75
Buy Now
etsy.com
Christmas Jewelry, Joy To The World Bracelet, Charm Gifts, Cuff Gift For Her, Swap
$19.95
Buy Now
etsy.com
Cookie Swap Gift Tags Holiday Baking, Pink Tag Set
$6.50
Buy Now
amazon.com
Yankee Candle Store Physical Gift Card - $50
$50.00
Buy Now
amazon.com
Santa Swap Gift Exchange Dice, 3 * 3in Exchange Gifts Family Game, Christmas Stocking Stuffers Gift
Wished for 31 times
$9.99
Buy Now
virginexperiencegifts.com
Romantic Helicopter Flight Aboard an Airbus AS350 - 45 Minute Flight ONLY | Flying Experience Gifts | Helicopter Tours | New York | Virgin Gifts / Vouchers
$1,780.00
Buy Now
virginexperiencegifts.com
Private Doors-On Helicopter Tour for Two Over the Brooklyn Bridge | Flying Experience Gifts | Helicopter Tours | New Jersey | Virgin Gifts / Vouchers
$614.00
Buy Now
etsy.com
Gingerbread Party Bag Cookie Exchange Swap Gift Personalized Christmas Tote
$16.00
Buy Now
virginexperiencegifts.com
From Westchester - Shared Helicopter Ride Over New York City for Two | Flying | Helicopter Tours | New Jersey | Virgin Gifts / Vouchers
$900.00
Buy Now
etsy.com
24K Gold Filled Pineapple Bracelet Swap Party Gift Fruit Jewelry
$41.70
Buy Now
Giftcards.com
Yankee Candle Physical Gift Card Giftcards. com
Wished for 1 time
$250.00
Buy Now
Giftcards.com
Yankee Candle Physical Gift Card Giftcards. com
Wished for 21 times
$50.00
Buy Now
virginexperiencegifts.com
Doors-Off Helicopter Tour for Two: Private Flight Over the Brooklyn Bridge | Flying Experience Gifts | Helicopter Tours | New Jersey | Virgin Gifts / Vouchers
$524.00
Buy Now
Giftcards.com
Yankee Candle Physical Gift Card Giftcards. com
Wished for 2 times
$100.00
Buy Now
virginexperiencegifts.com
Best of NYC Scenic Cruise | Scenic Cruises | Day Cruises | New Jersey | New York City | Virgin Gifts / Vouchers
$52.00
Buy Now
etsy.com
New York Yankees American Rustic Flag, Sign, Flag Wood Ny Yankees, Gift For Him, Her
$179.00
Buy Now
virginexperiencegifts.com
From Downtown Manhattan-Deluxe New York Helicopter Tour | Flying | Helicopter Tours | New York City | Virgin Gifts / Vouchers
$462.00
Buy Now
amazon.com
Yankee Coasters for Drinks, New York NY Ceramic Coasters Set of 6, Yankee Gifts for Boys Man, for Ya
Wished for 3 times
$15.99
Buy Now
amazon.com
Santa Swap Gift Exchange Dice Christmas Stocking Stuffers,Bookish Gifts,Reading Accessories for Book
Wished for 2 times
$6.59
Buy Now

Explore More Gift Idea

Home
Exchanges
Wishlists
Friends
Wish